top of page
  • Writer's pictureJeff Guymon

CarMax Lancaster

Updated: Apr 25, 2021

Before Heading to CarMax Lancaster - it's worth giving a few quick facts about the Lancaster location and what makes it so great compared to other locations.

Where is CarMax Lancaster Located?


Address: 1457 Manheim Pike Lancaster, PA 17601

Phone Number: (717) 239-7580

Hours of Operation:

Car lot & showroom hours

Monday - Friday: 10AM - 9PM

Saturday: 9AM - 9PM

Service Repair Hours

Monday - Friday: 7:30AM - 6PM

This location offers appointments and walk-ins, curbside purchases and curbside pickup, vehicle delivery within 60 miles, solo test drives, and a money-back guarantee.

NOTE: Stay informed on CarMax’s response to the COVID-19 pandemic at

What Are the Reviews Like for CarMax Lancaster?

Customers have generally reported positively about their experience at the Lancaster CarMax retailer(s). It’s expected that the car buying experience depends largely on who the car salesman is. Those who are fortunate to work with a good sales associate have praised them and the customer service they received. Likewise, poor reviews are left by those who worked with reps whose only goal was to sell cars without the buyer’s feelings and needs in mind.

Below are ratings from reputable sources:

  • Yelp: 2.5 out of 5 stars

Many customers expressed frustration regarding the service department. After purchasing vehicles from CarMax, customers reported having to come back not long after to deal with repairs. These buyers fault CarMax since they claim to conduct a 125+ point inspection on all vehicles.

How Many Vehicles Does CarMax Lancaster Offer?

As of January 2021, CarMax Lancaster has an available inventory of 171 vehicles. There are a wide variety of makes that are sold, but Honda, Nissan and Ford vehicles are primarily what you can expect to find at CarMax Lancaster. There is a good distribution of vehicle age ranging from 2010 and newer, though most cars are from model years 2017 to 2018. Mileage ranges from zero to 130,000 miles, but most vehicles fall somewhere between 20,000 to 30,000 existing miles.

How Are Cars at CarMax Lancaster Priced?

Most vehicles available at CarMax Lancaster cost anywhere from $10,000 to $20,000. More affordable vehicles you can expect to find are older or high mileage, sedan style vehicles. More expensive vehicles are newer (2018+) luxury models (e.g. Land Rover, Mercedes Benz, Audi, etc), reliable makes such as Honda and Toyota, as well as large SUVs and trucks.

What Percentage of the Lancaster Car Market Does CarMax Lancaster Have?

We searched CarGurus to get an idea of how many cars CarMax has available compared to the nearest stores around the city center. CarGurus’ listings of used cars in the Lancaster area that are 2010 and newer, as well as under 100,000 miles total 23,100 vehicles for sale. Based on that number, CarMax Lancaster accounts for a small portion of the total market at 0.74%.

Keep in mind that the CarGurus listings are of vehicles available across the Lancaster area, and at multiple locations. The advantage of going to CarMax is being able to compare a number of different vehicles at the same time.

Refinance with WithClutch

Purchasing a vehicle comes with the responsibility of beginning to pay it off. Oftentimes dealers charge very high interest rates. Whether you purchased from a dealer or a private-seller, WithClutch can help you save money and time by allowing you to refinance your loan from the comfort of your home! Use the free Auto Loan Refinance Calculator to find out how much you could save.

If this is something that appeals to you, follow these simple steps to begin your refinance journey and get you on the best payment plan to finally be free of your auto loan.

75 views0 comments


bottom of page